Frequently Asked Questions
General question
Students ask about how a positive retention rate could lead to a negative
PVGO.
The answer is that when shareholders are able to get a return higher than the
project’s ROE elsewhere, a positive retention rate would lead to a negative
PVGO as the company is not as efficient in generating returns as is the share-
holder by investing elsewhere. Hence in this situation (ROE < Required return
of shareholders) the shareholders would prefer the firm not to invest in its own
projects, but to invest themselves in external projects.